Is a CSA Farm Membership a Good Idea? ~Pros and Cons

• Tweet

• Tweet

I’ve watched Community Supported Agriculture (CSA) programs become more and more popular over the last several years. I run a successful CSA Farm here in Central Michigan and we do a year end survey that sheds light on what our members really like about the farm share program and the things they would change.  Producing naturally grown chemical free fruits and vegetables is our main income, it’s what we do, so it’s important to tailor the CSA around what our members say.  What we want, as a growing CSA farm, is for our existing members to renew each year and over time develop a core group of loyal CSA members.  They don’t all renew and I wanted to share more about why they don’t.

I’ve found over the years that people who are moving into the area that have participated in a CSA before are very likely to renew, in fact they almost always do.  I think this goes to the point that a Farm Share isn’t for everyone, but those who like it don’t want to be without it.  Joining a CSA won’t change your life or transform your eating habits, but it will be a great source of nutritious produce if you’ve decided to change what you eat and you will likely get a great variety of produce you probably wouldn’t have tried otherwise.

The Pros and Cons of a CSA Farm Membership

I’ll start with the “Cons”, which are really the reasons people don’t renew or suggestions they offer in our end of the year survey.  These obviously wouldn’t be negatives for everyone, but these are specific reasons and ideas that real members share about their CSA experience with us.  The nice thing about communicating with our members is that we can tweak or change the program to address most suggestions, usually we add flexibility and options to make the program more convenient and member centric.  Here are some of the Cons to becoming a CSA member:

• To much produce~ People don’t like the feeling they get when throwing food away.
• Missing the pick up because of other commitments means waiting a whole week for the next batch of fresh veggies.
• Getting items in the weekly share that your family doesn’t care for.
• Not being able to pick and choose which items you want and which items you don’t like you would do while shopping.
• CSA program are for a pre set time frame (ours is 18 weeks) Some people are in the area only during the summer.
• Pick up time or location may be difficult because of work commitments.
• The only items in the weekly share are ones grown in Michigan, so you’ll still go to the supermarket for bananas.

These are/were the top reasons people didn’t renew their CSA membership with the Central Michigan CSA.  We’ve added or changed things to address most all of these challenges and listen each year for new ideas that would make the program better.  Each CSA farm is different, hopefully these draw backs can help you ask good questions before you join a CSA where you live.  I imagine most successful CSA farms you find will also have addressed these main drawbacks just like we have.  In my experience the Pros, or positives, of a CSA membership far out weigh the Cons in terms of the feedback we receive each year.  Here are some of the most popular things that people love about their CSA memberships:

• Excellent variety of different vegetables and fruits.
• Forces me to try new vegetables that I wouldn’t have bought otherwise.
• Great tasting vegetables.
• The weekly shares are fresh picked that day or the night before and you can tell.
• They love knowing there aren’t any chemical residues on the food they are eating.
• It’s great to teach young children how to eat healthy and be aware of where your food comes from.
• We have farm days and many of our members really like coming out to the farm that they help successful.
• The CSA is a great economical value when compared to a grocery store or farmers market.
• The pick ups are at local farmers markets.
• Many members can and freeze a lot of produce they enjoy over the winter months.

These are some of the Pros to becoming a CSA member according to our current and past members.  All CSA farm shares are different and their members likely have specific things they really like about the program and others they would like to change.  We have a couple farm stands and our customers often ask about the CSA.  It’s simple to explain but I think it’s something that needs to be experienced to really understand.

Is Joining a CSA a Good Idea?

If you’ve never participated in a CSA program and want to know if its something you would like, then I recommend joining one.  Our members are overwhelmingly satisfied with their decision to become members of our CSA.  Most find that they eat way more fresh fruits and vegetables than they would have otherwise and find the weekly CSA pick up to be convenient.  I love to see members with young children,  I think it’s a great example to set for kids and it’s something they will remember.  Each CSA program is different and value varies.   We designed our CSA program for people who are feeding families and want value, some are more heavy on the “idealism” or novelty of eating nutritious food.  We like to keep it real and the baskets full.  Contact a CSA farm near you and talk with them about their program, you should get a good idea of how they approach the CSA membership, keep looking until you find a fit.